SO HARD NOT TO DANCE WHEN YOU HAVE EARPHONES ON WALKING BY YOURSELF
I think that it was Maya & Jenna that lead Toby away in the woods and hit him. (Yes Maya - no way she is really dead and Bianca Lawson was listed as being in that episode, i think the sillouette looked like her). Jenna was there and she did have a burn on her arm afterwards. She Also told Emily to pass on a message to Toby that she never meant to hurt him.
As for the compass engraved on the side of the lighter which highlighted the direction NW.
I think it could mean one of 3 things.
- What the show lead us to believe that it was Nigel Wright’s lighter and Jenna dropped it next to Toby to point him in Nigels Direction so he would go see him and be told the Lie about CeCe changing the plane flight path. Dont forget someone with Jenna’s glasses and Cane told Nigel to tell them it was CeCe. Which could mean Jenna was covering for Alison who I believe truly flew the plane. But i don’t know why she would do this.
- A reference to the Hitchcock movie North by Northwest (read plot here)
- Or it could relate to this theory I did ages ago and It was Jenna’s way of reminding toby about what he had done for her and who’s side he should be on.